MINEOLA, N.Y. (TIP): Republican candidates scored a decisive victory across Nassau County on Nov. 4, delivering what local party leaders called a mandate to continue the GOP’s law-and-order and tax- restraint agenda on Long Island. With all 1,097 precincts reporting, the GOP swept the countywide contests — most prominently re-electing incumbent County Executive Bruce Blakeman and returning Anne Donnelly to the District Attorney’s office — while holding other countywide posts and key town offices.
Blakeman — who campaigned on public safety, fiscal restraint and opposition to sanctuary policies — declared victory late Tuesday, November 4, as returns showed him with a clear margin over Democratic challenger and County Legislator Seth Koslow. The Nassau County Board of Elections’ unofficial tally put Blakeman ahead by roughly 55.8% to 44.2%, a result that preserves Republican control of the executive seat Blakeman first won in 2021.
“It’s an honor to keep serving the people of this county,” Blakeman told supporters at his victory party in Mineola, praising police unions and law-enforcement endorsements that buoyed his re-election bid. Local GOP leaders hailed the results as proof that voters in Nassau — one of the most closely watched suburban counties in the state — remain supportive of a more conservative approach to crime and fiscal policy. In the DA’s race, incumbent Anne Donnelly cruised to a second term, defeating Democratic prosecutor Nicole Aloise. Donnelly, who emphasized prosecutions of gun crimes and a tougher stance on violent offenders, won with a comfortable margin in unofficial returns that put her vote share in the mid-50s percentage range. Her victory ensures continuity in the county’s prosecutorial approach during a period when public safety was a dominant campaign theme.
Democratic campaigns had hoped high-profile local and statewide issues — housing costs, property taxes and the national political climate — would help flip Nassau back toward the Democrats this year. Instead, Republican turnout edged Democrats in early voting and election day participation in several key precincts, a pattern that analysts say tilted tight contests in the GOP’s favor. The Nassau County Board of Elections reported roughly 313,184 ballots cast countywide in the general election.
The Democratic candidates conceded reluctantly in several races. Seth Koslow — who ran on a platform of government transparency, property-tax relief for homeowners and investments in county services — called his loss “disappointing” but urged his supporters to keep organizing locally. Koslow’s campaign had sought to tie some county-level fiscal pressures to the executive administration, but the margin was not enough to unseat the incumbent.
Local political observers said the results reflected a blend of incumbency advantage, effective local GOP messaging on public safety and endorsements from law-enforcement groups that resonated with suburban voters worried about crime. Nassau Republicans also benefited from a well-funded ground game and a string of advertising that framed the election as a choice between stability and change — an argument that, in the end, played better for the incumbents.
Beyond the headline countywide races, Republicans held onto other crucial local posts, including several town supervisor seats and legislative districts that Democrats had targeted earlier in the year. The sweep extends the GOP’s control over the county’s administrative apparatus and gives Blakeman and allied officials a clearer runway to pursue priorities next year.
Democrats and progressive activists — still celebrating some high-profile wins elsewhere in the state, including in New York City — warned against reading the Nassau results as a wholesale rejection of their agenda. They pointed to structural factors such as turnout differences, local issue salience and the power of incumbency. “We’ll be back,” said a senior county Democrat, noting that Nassau’s voter rolls still show a Democratic registration advantage, and promising a reorganized strategy aimed at next year’s cycles.
What the sweep means in practical terms: expect an immediate focus on stricter enforcement priorities from the DA’s office and proposals from the executive’s office that prioritize law enforcement budgets and oppose any local moves that would limit cooperation with federal immigration authorities. Blakeman’s re-election also revives questions about his political future; local media and party operatives have already speculated about higher-profile runs, though the county executive said he was focused on governing.
Voters who backed Democrats expressed concern about rising costs and housing pressures, issues that will likely remain central in Nassau for the foreseeable future. For Democrats, the task now is to translate criticism about local conditions into a winning message that can overcome the incumbents’ law-and-order advantage. For Republicans, the challenge is to deliver on promises while keeping suburban swing voters engaged through the next cycles.
Officials on both sides stressed the importance of looking beyond the immediate headlines. County Board of Elections staff emphasized that the posted results were unofficial until certification, and canvassing and audits planned in the coming weeks will finalize vote counts and close the books on the Nov. 4 contests. Still, with every precinct now tallied and margins clear in most countywide races, the outcome is unlikely to change dramatically.
As night fell on a high-turnout Tuesday in Nassau County, Republicans toasted a clean sweep that will shape county policy for the next four years. Democrats pledged to regroup and keep fighting in local towns and legislative districts where they see openings. For residents of Nassau, the result closes one chapter of a closely watched political tug-of-war on Long Island — and opens another in which local government, budgets and public-safety debates will move to the fore.
(Reporting compiled from Nassau County Board of Elections data and coverage by Newsday, Long Island Press, WSHU, local outlets, and official campaign statements.)
