Indian Americans at USA-250: A call for humility and Reciprocity

The writer with A. P. J. Abdul Kalam, Engineer and former President of India, much admired and loved for his humility.
  • By George Abraham

The story of America is, above all, a story of freedom, particularly the quest for religious freedom. The Pilgrims who arrived on American shores were English Separatists determined to worship God according to the dictates of their conscience. In 1620, a group of 102 men, women, and children set sail from Plymouth, England, aboard the Mayflower. Their transatlantic journey was marked by untold hardships, including rough seas, overcrowding, illness, and food and water shortages. After a perilous voyage, the ship reached Cape Cod in November 1620. Historical accounts indicate that Dorothy Bradford, the wife of the Pilgrims’ leader, William Bradford, drowned stepping out of the boat upon arrival. During the harsh winter that followed, nearly half of the settlers perished from severe cold, disease, and deprivation.
Yet their story is one of extraordinary faith, perseverance, and an unwavering pursuit of freedom. These men and women braved the seas and conquered a new frontier in search of the liberty to live, worship, and pursue their dreams. Through hard work, sacrifice, and remarkable resilience, they laid the foundations of a nation that would become the envy of the world and a beacon of hope for billions. Their journey reminds us that America’s greatness was built not merely on prosperity and power, but on the enduring ideals of faith, freedom, and human dignity.
America’s founding was deeply influenced by Judeo-Christian values and traditions, and the nation has inherited a rich Christian heritage that many newer generations and immigrants often overlook. While the Founding Fathers embraced religious liberty and the separation of church and state, many of the moral principles that shaped the nation’s institutions, human dignity, individual responsibility, compassion for the less fortunate, equality before God, and the rule of law were rooted in the Judeo-Christian tradition.
Many of the early immigrants who arrived from Europe shared these religious beliefs and common ideals, helping to forge a society characterized by faith, hard work, personal sacrifice, and a commitment to the common good. These values played an important role in shaping a nation whose citizens have consistently demonstrated remarkable generosity and compassion.
Few countries in history have matched the United States in responding to humanitarian crises worldwide. Whether in times of war, famine, natural disasters, or political upheaval, America has repeatedly extended a helping hand to those in need. Millions of refugees and immigrants fleeing persecution, poverty, and oppression have found safety and opportunity on its shores. Likewise, American citizens, churches, charities, and humanitarian organizations have been among the first to provide relief and assistance to victims of disasters and conflicts worldwide.
America has long been described as a melting pot, a nation where successive waves of immigrants assimilated and embraced a common American identity while preserving the best elements of their cultural heritage. One of the most compelling examples of this commitment to the adopted homeland is the story of Dwight D. Eisenhower. Although Eisenhower himself was born in Texas, his ancestors were German immigrants who had settled in America generations earlier. Yet when the world was engulfed in war, Eisenhower harbored no divided loyalty. As Supreme Commander of the Allied Expeditionary Force during World War II, he led the D-Day invasion of Normandy on June 6, 1944, a campaign that marked the beginning of the end of Nazi Germany. Later, he served as the 34th President of the United States from 1953 to 1961.

America’s history has never been perfect. Like all nations, it has made its share of mistakes and endured periods of division and injustice. Yet one of the enduring strengths of the American experiment has been its capacity for self-correction and renewal. Through visionary leadership, exemplified by figures such as Abraham Lincoln, and through constitutional and legislative reforms, the nation has repeatedly sought to address its shortcomings and move closer to its founding ideals. While the journey has often been imperfect and unfinished, America’s ability to confront its failures and strive for a more just and inclusive society remains one of its most remarkable characteristics.
Like every nation, America continues to face its own challenges. Yet few would dispute that it remains that “shining city upon a hill,” a place to which the poor, the oppressed, and the aspiring continue to look with hope. As Indian Americans, our journey may not have been one of political refugees fleeing persecution, but many of us came as economic migrants seeking opportunities to use our God-given talents not only to achieve personal success but also to contribute to the prosperity and advancement of our adopted homeland.
Our challenge today is different. At a time when the nation appears increasingly polarized along ethnic, racial, and ideological lines, we have an opportunity and a responsibility to become agents of healing and reconciliation. While we rightly take pride in our heritage, we should celebrate our identity as Americans even more. We need not diminish our cultural roots, but neither should we define ourselves solely by them. We can honor our traditions while embracing the customs, values, and institutions of the country that has welcomed us so generously. Loyalty to our adopted nation and pride in our heritage are not mutually exclusive; indeed, they can complement one another.
As we celebrate the 250th anniversary of this great nation, it is also an appropriate time for introspection within our own community. The remarkable success achieved by Indian Americans over the past several decades has earned us admiration and respect. Yet success also brings responsibilities. We must continually ask ourselves how we are perceived by our fellow Americans and whether our actions are strengthening our bonds with the larger society.
There is nothing wrong with taking pride in our heritage, culture, and traditions. Indeed, America’s strength lies in its diversity, and every immigrant community has enriched the nation’s social fabric. However, pride should always be tempered with humility and sensitivity. At times, excessive displays of cultural triumphalism and an “in-your-face” approach to promoting our identity may inadvertently create misunderstandings and even resentment. Rather than fostering appreciation, such attitudes can be perceived as expressions of cultural or religious superiority, undermining the goodwill that generations of immigrants have worked so hard to build.
Many of us enthusiastically celebrate every festival and holiday associated with our ancestral homeland, which is entirely understandable. Yet we often devote far less energy to celebrating the national holidays and traditions that have shaped our adopted country. The Fourth of July, Thanksgiving, Memorial Day, Veterans Day, and other occasions that embody the American experience deserve equal recognition and appreciation from those of us who have benefited so greatly from this land.

Similarly, we sometimes passionately advocate for recognition of our own religious and cultural observances in public institutions, including school closings, while remaining largely silent when concerns are raised about the perilous status of Christmas, Easter, or other holidays in India that are deeply meaningful to many Americans. Consistency and reciprocity are important virtues in a pluralistic society. Respect for diversity should not be a one-way street.
Likewise, public celebrations and religious processions are cherished traditions, but they should always be conducted with consideration for the broader community. Activities that inconvenience or disrupt others’ daily lives can unintentionally alienate neighbors and reinforce negative stereotypes. Living in a diverse society requires balancing the right to celebrate one’s heritage with a responsibility to be considerate of others.
Another area that deserves reflection is our response to human suffering. Indian Americans have demonstrated extraordinary generosity in responding to natural disasters and crises in India. That spirit of compassion is commendable and should continue. At the same time, we should be equally visible in responding to tragedies and disasters here in the United States. When hurricanes, floods, wildfires, or other emergencies strike our adopted homeland, our voices and our resources should be present as well. Compassion, after all, should know no geographical boundaries.
Recent generations of immigrants are among the greatest beneficiaries of the legacy of hard work, sacrifice, and perseverance built by those who came before them. Over the centuries, America became a magnet for millions of people from every culture, language, and faith, offering opportunities unmatched elsewhere in history. If this great experiment is to continue to succeed, however, we must follow in the footsteps of those who paved the way, embracing personal responsibility, hard work, and a commitment to the common good. It is a sad reality that 47% of all households headed by a foreign born depend on public assistance.
There are legitimate concerns about the long-term sustainability of social welfare programs and the need to encourage economic self-sufficiency and upward mobility among all segments of society. The vitality of any nation depends not only on opportunity but also on the willingness of its citizens and residents to contribute to the prosperity and well-being of the broader community.
Equally troubling is the tendency of some to disparage or seek to dismantle the very institutions and values that have enabled America to become the most prosperous economy in human history. Criticism and reform are essential elements of democracy, but they should be guided by a desire to strengthen rather than destroy. It is fair to ask why those who have benefited from the opportunities afforded by this country would seek to undermine the system that made those opportunities possible.
America’s institutions were not built overnight. They are the product of generations of sacrifice, innovation, and civic responsibility. Those who inherit this remarkable legacy have a responsibility not merely to enjoy its benefits, but to preserve, improve, and pass them on to future generations.
Assimilation does not require abandoning one’s roots, nor does patriotism demand forgetting one’s heritage. The genius of America has always been its ability to allow people from different backgrounds to become fully American while preserving the best of their cultural traditions. As we commemorate America’s 250th anniversary, perhaps the greatest tribute we can offer is to strive for a healthier balance, one that enables us to remain proud of our Indian heritage while embracing more deeply the values, traditions, and responsibilities that come with being Americans.
Eisenhower’s life exemplifies the American ideal that loyalty to one’s adopted country transcends ancestral origins. His story illustrates how immigrants and their descendants have embraced American values, contributed to the nation’s greatness, and demonstrated that being proud of one’s heritage and fully committed to America are not mutually exclusive but complementary.
(George Abraham is Vice-Chairman of IOC USA, and a former UN Chief Technological Officer. He can be reached at gta777@gmail.com)

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.